The Great Awakenings and Their Impact

What happens when entire nations tremble under the weight of conviction and joyfully turn back to God? In the story of the Great Awakenings, we find some of the most powerful revivals in church history — moments when sleepy churches awakened, hardened hearts melted, and gospel truth thundered across the land.

The Great Awakenings, spanning from the early 18th to the late 19th centuries, weren’t just religious moments. They were spiritual earthquakes that redefined Christian identity in the New World. These movements stirred deep questions: What is true conversion? Who should preach the gospel? How should Christians engage the world around them?

Today, amid spiritual apathy and cultural confusion, we must look back to these revivals — not to idolize them, but to learn. Were these awakenings merely emotional outbursts? Or did they bear lasting fruit rooted in biblical truth? Most importantly: could we see such revival again?

---

📜 The Story of the Great Awakenings

First Great Awakening (1730s–1740s): Awakening to Grace in the Colonies

The First Great Awakening erupted in the American colonies during a time when Christianity had grown formal, intellectual, and, for many, spiritually lifeless. The colonial churches were often tied to state systems, and sermons leaned more on moral instruction than gospel transformation.

Key figures rose to the forefront:

• Jonathan Edwards — A brilliant theologian and pastor in Massachusetts, his sermon “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” vividly portrayed divine judgment and mercy. Edwards emphasized the necessity of personal conversion and justification by faith.
• George Whitefield — A dynamic English preacher, Whitefield traveled up and down the colonies, preaching in open fields to thousands. His voice, said to reach 30,000 people without amplification, called listeners to new birth and repentance.
• John Wesley (in England) — While not in America, Wesley’s Methodism helped shape the revivalist spirit, emphasizing “heart religion” over dry formalism.

The revival transcended denominational lines and drew massive crowds. People were convicted of sin, wept openly, and cried out for mercy. It emphasized:

• Personal conversion over cultural Christianity
• Heartfelt piety over dead orthodoxy
• The priesthood of all believers, challenging elitist clergy structures

However, not all embraced the revival. Theologians like Charles Chauncy criticized its emotionalism, sparking a divide between the “Old Lights” (traditionalists) and “New Lights” (revivalists).

Second Great Awakening (1790s–1840s): Expanding the Frontiers of Faith

As America pushed westward after the Revolutionary War, so too did the gospel. The Second Great Awakening lit fires in rural areas, frontier camp meetings, and newly forming towns. This was a broader and even more populist revival than the first.

Leading voices included:

• Charles Grandison Finney — A lawyer-turned-preacher, Finney’s “new measures” included altar calls and emotional appeals. He emphasized human responsibility in salvation and pushed for social reform, including abolitionism.
• Francis Asbury — A pioneering Methodist bishop who organized circuit-riding preachers, Asbury expanded Christianity into the American heartland.
• Lyman Beecher — Though cautious of Finney’s methods, Beecher supported revival preaching and later fathered a generation of reformers, including Harriet Beecher Stowe.

This awakening transformed American Protestantism through:

• Revival meetings and camp gatherings in Kentucky, Tennessee, and beyond
• Emphasis on free will and personal choice in salvation
• Evangelistic expansion across denominational lines
• Moral activism, linking faith with temperance, abolition, and women’s rights

Unlike the First Awakening, which focused on personal conversion and theological clarity, the Second fused revival with reform. Christianity became not only about getting to heaven but also transforming society.

The Third Awakening (1850s–1900s): Urban Revival and Global Mission

Some historians debate its definition, but a Third Awakening emerged in the mid-19th century, marked by:

• Urban revivalism (led by preachers like D.L. Moody)
• Lay-led prayer movements, such as the Fulton Street Prayer Revival in New York
• Global missions and the rise of Bible and tract societies

This period was less about explosive revival meetings and more about organized evangelism. The Civil War, industrialization, and waves of immigration brought moral and social upheaval. In response, Christians launched:

• City-wide crusades
• YMCA programs and Sunday schools
• Global missionary efforts to Africa, Asia, and the Pacific

The emphasis moved from rural frontiers to urban centers, from spontaneous meetings to institutional outreach.

---

📖 Spiritual and Doctrinal Discernment

What can we make of these revivals? Were they truly of God?

Evident Biblical Truths

1. Regeneration is essential: The Awakenings reminded the Church that no one is saved by birth or behavior, but by being born again (John 3:3).
2. The power of the preached Word: Faith comes by hearing (Rom. 10:17). Bold preaching — not gimmicks — turned sinners to God.
3. Conviction precedes comfort: Like Peter at Pentecost, people were “cut to the heart” before finding joy. Revival always brings repentance before rejoicing.
4. Laypeople matter: The Awakenings broke down clerical hierarchies. Ordinary men and women led prayers, shared testimonies, and spread the gospel.
5. True faith bears fruit: Many conversions led to lasting discipleship and social engagement, especially in the Second Awakening.

Areas of Concern and Excess

1. Emotionalism over truth: Some critics rightly warned against shallow, emotional responses that lacked genuine regeneration.
2. Pelagian leanings: Finney, in particular, downplayed human depravity and exalted human will, risking distortion of the gospel.
3. Fragmentation of denominations: The emphasis on revival sometimes created new sects or splinter groups.
4. Mixed motivations in reform: While abolitionism and temperance were godly causes, some reforms became politically driven rather than spiritually led.

In short, the Spirit was at work, but not every revivalist method or message was biblically sound. Discernment remains crucial.

---

🔄 Lasting Impact: Shaping Christianity in America and Beyond

The Great Awakenings shaped American Christianity more than any other movements. Their legacy includes:

• Evangelical identity: The term “born again” became central to Protestant faith.
• Revivalism as a model: From Billy Sunday to Billy Graham, the revivalistic pattern lives on.
• Voluntary societies: Christian organizations for missions, Bible distribution, and charity were birthed in this era.
• Social conscience: Christian movements against slavery, child labor, and alcohol began with revived hearts.

Even today, phrases like “altar call,” “personal decision for Christ,” and “come forward” trace their roots to these revival traditions.

---

🪞 Reflection: What Should We Learn or Repent Of?

The Great Awakenings call us to examine both our theology and our temperature.

• Are we intellectually sound but spiritually cold?
• Have we reduced the gospel to morality or self-improvement?
• Are we relying on programs instead of prayer?

At the same time, we must ask:

• Do we long for true revival — or just religious excitement?
• Do our churches preach repentance and grace with urgency?
• Are we seeking the Spirit through humble dependence, not manipulation?

These awakenings remind us: God revives not because we schedule it — but because we seek Him earnestly (2 Chronicles 7:14).

---

📣 Why This Still Matters: Walking Forward in Truth

The Great Awakenings were not perfect. But they show what can happen when God’s people humble themselves, preach boldly, and pray fervently.

In our day of post-Christian confusion and apathetic religion, we must ask: Will we settle for spiritual maintenance, or cry out for true renewal?

Let us seek the kind of revival that begins in the heart, flows through the church, and spills into the world — not manufactured, but birthed by God’s Spirit.

May we remember the cry of the psalmist:

“Will you not revive us again, that your people may rejoice in you?”
— Psalm 85:6

Revival is not a method. It is a mercy. And it begins today — in you.